VGTRK pointed out the lack of transparency of UNESCO reports on the dead journalists
UNESCO uses an opaque methodology for selecting media staff when preparing reports on dead journalists. On November 20, Peter Fedorov, director of the Directorate of International Relations at VGTRK, told Izvestia.
"They explained to us that there is a selection methodology. It is not transparent, it does not satisfy me, as a beginner in this business, <...> but the explanations why some were included and others were not included are covered by methodology," he stressed.
Fedorov stressed that when forming reports, not only data provided by states is taken into account, but also information from non-governmental organizations, including Reporters Without Borders (recognized as an undesirable organization in the Russian Federation). At the same time, the representative of VGTRK questioned the objectivity of such structures, pointing out the closeness of the criteria by which they select the names of dead journalists.
"The situation looks like there is no equality in the selection. This, in particular, was now witnessed by the Palestinian delegation, which presented a huge list of dead journalists, of which only a small part was included in the report," Fedorov said.
He also drew attention to the unequal treatment of journalists who died outside the areas of interest of NATO and the European Union. According to the representative of VGTRK, the delegations of Palestine, Burkina Faso and Egypt, among others, point to this problem.
Fedorov added that media employees who died outside the context of NATO operations and the interests of European countries actually find themselves in the position of "second-class" journalists. He attributed this to the lack of transparency of UNESCO's methodology, which allows the organization not to explain why some names end up in reports while others remain outside them.
The military commanders of Izvestia on November 19 expressed their bewilderment at the UNESCO report on their dead colleagues and stated that now the press can expect anything from the organization. On November 19, UNESCO Senior Spokeswoman Claire O'Hagan explained to Izvestia that the agency was already reviewing the appeals received. At the same time, she noted that the statistics are included only after a number of international organizations confirm that the death of a journalist occurred precisely in the line of duty.
On November 16, the Russian Foreign Ministry said that the Russian Union of Journalists had sent an open letter to UNESCO due to the absence of a number of Russian journalists in the report on press safety. In particular, the documents did not contain information about the dead journalists of Izvestia— Semen Yeremin (died on April 19, 2024) and Alexander Martemyanov (January 4, 2025). Because of this, representatives of the holding sent a personal appeal to the Director General of UNESCO demanding that the names of employees be included in their statistics.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»