Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The speech of US Secretary of State Rubio in Munich has stirred up Europe. What the media is writing

Associated Press: Europeans reject US claims of "destruction of civilization"
0
Photo: Alex Brandon/Pool via REUTERS
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

One of the main events of the Munich Security Conference, which took place on February 13-15, was a speech by US Secretary of State Marco Rubio. He diplomatically called on Europe to cooperate, but criticized it for the same problems pointed out by US President Donald Trump. The European Union received the speech ambiguously and is inclined to further break with the United States. What the world's media write about relations between Washington and Brussels is in the Izvestia digest.

NBC News: Rubio had warmer words for Europe than Trump

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio spoke at the Munich Security Conference in an apparent attempt to smooth over differences in relations between the US and Europe, although foreign diplomats were not sure if real changes would follow. His direct appeal to Europe stands in stark contrast to President Donald Trump's disparaging remarks at Davos last month, when the US leader declared that part of Europe was "being destroyed" and said the US had "gained nothing" from NATO membership.

NBC News

Rubio received a standing ovation for his emotional speech in Munich, in which he addressed a predominantly European audience.: "At a time when the headlines herald the end of the transatlantic era, let everyone know and understand that this is neither our goal nor our desire, because for us Americans, our home may be in the Western Hemisphere, but we will always be the children of Europe."

However, some foreign diplomats in the audience were skeptical that this speech reflected real changes in the Trump administration's position. In his speech, Rubio sharply criticized Europe's migration and climate policies, warning that the "unprecedented" level of mass migration threatens "the cohesion of our societies, the continuity of our culture and the future of our peoples." He also criticized the UN, saying that it "practically did not play any role" in major world events from Gaza to Ukraine, and defended the US interventions in Venezuela and Iran.

Associated Press: Europeans reject US claims of "destruction of civilization"

The head of the European Union's foreign policy department, Kaya Kallas, spoke at the Munich Security Conference the day after US Secretary of State Marco Rubio addressed European allies with a somewhat encouraging message. He took a less aggressive stance than Vice President Jay D. Vance, who addressed them at the same meeting last year, but maintained a firm stance on Washington's intentions to rebuild the transatlantic alliance and advance its political priorities.

Associated Press

Callas mentioned the criticism contained in the US national Security strategy, published in December, which argued that economic stagnation in Europe is "overshadowed by the real and darker prospect of the destruction of civilization." It suggested that Europe was being weakened by its migration policy, declining birth rates, "censorship of freedom of speech and suppression of political opposition," as well as "loss of national identity and self-confidence."

Callas rejected what she called an "insult to Europe." She stated that Europe "is not on the verge of civilization disappearing," and noted that during a visit to Canada last year, she was told that many there were interested in joining the EU. While Rubio made it clear that the US administration would stick to its position on issues such as migration, trade and climate, European officials who addressed the gathering said they would remain true to their values, including their approach to freedom of speech, climate change and free trade.

Financial Times: Rubio's call for unity in Munich finds no response in Europe

Rubio reinforced his speech with assurances that the "unbreakable bond" between the United States and Europe has existed since European settlers arrived on the American continent. The crowd of European leaders, ministers, and high-ranking officials jumped to their feet and applauded, but not so much out of admiration as out of relief. Although Rubio's tone was more polite than Vance's, the essence of the U.S. message remained the same.

Financial Times

"Rubio is the best we can expect from the [US] administration,— said one senior European minister who attended the meeting. "But he made it clear that if transatlantic relations have not been severed, they are significantly different from those to which we are accustomed." According to European officials, in many ways, Vance's speech in 2025 was easier to handle because it was so overtly aggressive that it ensured unity in response. According to them, because of the nuances in Rubio's speech, it was more difficult to determine what the threat was.

Immediately after Rubio's speech, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen made it clear that despite the change in rhetoric, relations between the United States and Europe remain extremely tense. According to one senior EU diplomat, Rubio's true message for the continent was his visit to Slovakia on Sunday, followed by a trip to Hungary— the two countries of greatest concern to Brussels. The level of concern is such that even Germany, a country that has always refused Paris' offers to join the French nuclear umbrella and relied on the American atomic shield, is considering changing its position.

Reuters: Europe seeks to depend less on U.S. defense

Transatlantic relations between Europe and the United States have already been strained over the past year due to Trump's return to the White House. But the US president's drive to annex Greenland has dramatically increased doubts in Europe about Washington's commitment to defending the continent within the framework of NATO. Rubio gave only limited assurances to the Europeans in his speech in Munich. He stated that the United States wants to cooperate with Europe, but did not mention the issues on which there was a gap between the United States and its partners in the alliance.

Reuters

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, French President Emmanuel Macron and British Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Munich reaffirmed their commitment to strengthening the "European pillar" within NATO. But a stronger internal defense is also insurance against the fact that Trump or the future leader of the United States will decide not to defend Europe. "This new beginning is right under any circumstances. It is right if the United States continues to distance itself. It's right until we can guarantee our own security on our own," Merz said at a conference on Friday.

The main question for Europe and its leaders is whether they will be able to back up their words with deeds — to purchase and develop new weapons systems, fill gaps in their arsenals in areas such as long-range missiles, and coordinate their work. So far, the signs are mixed. Some large-scale pan-European projects are struggling to move forward. The future of the Franco-German-Spanish FCAS fighter project has been in doubt for several months now, as the partners have been unable to agree on the distribution of work between the participating companies. Discussions on European Union defense projects were accompanied by arguments about whether their participation should be limited to EU companies or opened to other countries.

Bloomberg: Trump's new world order pushes Sweden to move closer to the eurozone

After Sweden's abrupt change of position regarding NATO membership, it is beginning to consider another historical shift: the transition to the euro. Although the discussion is at an early stage, as conditions change, there is a subtle but noticeable shift. In 2003, when voters rejected the single European currency in a referendum, the focus was on the krona's ability to act as a buffer for the largest Scandinavian economy, but now geopolitical considerations have taken on new depth.

Bloomberg

"Sweden is now a full member of NATO, and we are strengthening our defenses together with our EU partners," Cecilia Renn, a member of the Swedish Liberal Party, said in an interview in the Stockholm parliament. "But we still have one foot outside the system because we don't participate in currency cooperation."

The argument in favor of the euro is that the single currency will strengthen political ties and provide Swedes with the opportunity to participate in pan-European currency issues. This complements traditional commercial arguments such as expanding trade and facilitating direct investment. If this trend does strengthen, it will boost confidence in the euro at a time when the dollar's dominance in global trade and as a reserve currency is being questioned.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast